🐔 Why Did the Chicken Cross the Road (and Why Do We Go to Coffee Shops to Work)? Behavioral Science for Workplace Innovation 🧠

Deep Thoughs and Whatnots™

🐔 Why Did the Chicken Cross the Road (and Why Do We Go to Coffee Shops to Work)? Behavioral Science for Workplace Innovation 🧠

Play Episode Pause Episode

Mute/Unmute Episode Rewind 10 Seconds 1x Fast Forward 30 seconds

00:00 / 18:18

Apple Podcasts Spotify

RSS Feed

Share

Link

Embed

🐔 “Why did the chicken cross the road?” It’s an age-old question that seems simple—until you start peeling back layers of assumptions. The go-to answer might be “to get to the other side,” but that’s the lazy “why.” What if there were more than one chicken? More than one road? Or better yet, what if each chicken had its own reason for crossing?

We do this all the time in business too. We jump to the first answer, the most obvious solution. But as the saying goes, “There’s more than one reason—and more than one chicken.” Getting stuck on the surface answer can blind us to creative possibilities, especially when it comes to workplace engagement, training, and productivity.

So, let’s look at a modern-day “road-crossing” phenomenon: working from coffee shops. Why do so many people choose to work there despite having the option to stay home or be in a structured office? We often assume it’s just for the caffeine hit, the change of scene, or the background hum. But what if it’s something deeper?

Here’s what’s really going on, according to behavioral science:

1. Social Proof Without Engagement

Coffee shops provide a unique type of social visibility—a passive sense of community that motivates without requiring engagement. Observing others working around you creates a subtle “productive peer pressure.” It’s as if the collective energy in the room says, “We’re in this together,” even though no one’s interacting directly. This sense of shared purpose is often absent in a solitary home office, and it’s the kind of energy we crave.

2. Environmental Reframing

Our usual environments come with default thinking patterns. At home, it’s hard to feel focused because it’s a place for relaxation. In a structured office, the formality can make everything feel routine. Coffee shops offer a “third space”—a fresh context that nudges the brain into a new perspective, encouraging creativity and focus. It’s like an instant mental reset. In the coffee shop, work doesn’t feel like work; it feels like possibility.

3. Productive Background Noise

There’s something uniquely productive about the background noise of a coffee shop. Studies show that moderate ambient noise, like café chatter, helps focus better than silence or loud disruptions. This “white noise” drowns out distracting thoughts and minor interruptions without demanding full attention. It’s the sweet spot—enough activity to stay alert, but not enough to derail your flow.

4. Mini-Rituals for Purposeful Structure

From ordering your favorite drink to choosing a spot, working in a coffee shop comes with little rituals. Behavioral science tells us that these rituals help us feel intentional, adding a sense of purpose to each action. These small routines make the workspace feel intentional, structured, and different from the usual.

5. Escaping the Default Narratives of Home and Office

Home feels too casual; the office can feel too rigid. The coffee shop becomes a “just right” blend where work doesn’t have the same fixed narrative. It’s a neutral space that gives us freedom to approach tasks differently, fueling productivity in a subtle but powerful way.

6. Embracing Ambiguity and Unpredictability

Coffee shops are ambiguous spaces—part social hub, part workspace, part escape. They embody what behavioral scientist Rory Sutherland calls “behavioral alchemy,” the power of non-logical environments to spark unexpected results. This blend of purposes satisfies our need for flexibility and variety, making it a perfect match for those who thrive on choice and change.

Bridging Back to the Chicken

Just like the question of why the chicken crossed the road, it’s easy to oversimplify why people choose to work from coffee shops. But looking closer reveals layers of behavioral needs that coffee shops uniquely satisfy. As Sutherland points out, understanding the “why” of human behaviors opens new solution spaces, sparking innovative answers that go beyond the obvious.

So, the next time you see someone working away in a coffee shop, think of it as their journey across multiple levels of social connection, environmental change, and productive noise. And maybe, just maybe, there’s more than one reason—and more than one chicken—behind that journey.

Finding Your Company’s “Why Did the Chicken Cross the Road?” Moment

Every workplace has its own “why did the chicken cross the road” moment, especially when it comes to behavior change and engagement. We ask employees to “get to the other side”—to complete training, adopt new skills, or embrace new ideas—but too often, we overlook the behavioral environment. We assume people can focus simply because they should, forgetting that where and how people learn matters.

Take a common scenario: asking employees to complete a training module during the workday. They’re often surrounded by distractions—emails, alerts, and interruptions that compete for attention. Yet we expect them to engage fully, without adjusting the setting.

What if, instead of forcing people to “train” amidst the chaos, we changed the context? Imagine giving each employee a small coffee voucher and encouraging them to head to a nearby café to complete the training. A fresh environment, free from typical workplace distractions, encourages focus and absorption. Sure, it’s unconventional, but the cost of ineffective training far outweighs the price of a coffee.

Now, in more structured settings, like a medical center, sending employees off to Starbucks may not be practical. But small, thoughtful adjustments can still make a difference. What if, for instance, employees were invited to a private room away from the chaos of the day, given a laptop that isn’t their regular work machine, and offered a cup of coffee or tea? With a comfortable chair and a momentary break from routine, they’d be able to focus fully on the training. These small touches, together, create an experience stack—a layered approach to engagement that makes each element exponentially more effective.

Reinforcing the Learning: Building in a Feedback Loop

To deepen the impact of the training, we can create a simple yet powerful feedback loop. Imagine that after each session in the learning room, employees leave a sticky note on the wall with a takeaway or a phrase that resonated. Over time, these notes become a “wall of learning,” a physical reminder of shared insights and takeaways. This not only reinforces each participant’s learning but adds a layer of social proof—publicly showcasing what others have learned. Knowing that others will see their note creates a small accountability nudge, encouraging everyone to engage meaningfully.

When we ask people to pause their day and engage with training, the least we can do is make the experience intentional, inviting, and worth their focus—not just another item on a long to-do list.

The Real Takeaway: Rethink the Lazy “Why”

The real message here? Don’t settle for the surface-level solution. Avoid the lazy “why” in your organization. Think beyond the usual response to “why did the chicken cross the road” and embrace a mindset that asks why and how people engage with each task. Look for behavioral tweaks—nudges, reframing, environmental shifts—that can make a real difference. The best solutions often come from challenging the status quo and finding the hidden reasons behind actions.

So, what’s your company’s version of “why did the chicken cross the road?” And how can you use the behavioral insights we explored in the coffee shop setting to rethink your approach and discover new ways to improve engagement? Embracing this mindset won’t just change how you approach challenges—it’ll open new pathways to innovation, engagement, and, ultimately, success.

And remember: “There’s more than one reason—and more than one chicken.” Keep asking the deeper questions, and you might be surprised where the answers take you.

Rabbit Hole: I’ve been experimenting with NoteBookLM and creating podcasts like this from Deep Thoughts and Whatnots. You might be surprised how good it’s getting.

🔗 DT&W on Apple Podcasts

📌 And just like that “wall of learning” I mentioned, this entire article is my own “sticky note”—my reflection on the insights I gained from watching an inspiring video by Rory Sutherland. If you’re curious, here’s the link to the video that sparked these ideas: Rory Sutherland on Behavioral Science.

If you watch it, I’d love to see your own “sticky notes” in the comments! Share a thought, takeaway, or something that resonated with you. Let’s build our own wall of learning right here.